| The White House President George W. Bush |
Print this document |
For Immediate Release
Office of the Press Secretary
October 29, 2001
Press Briefing by Ari Fleischer
The James S. Brady Briefing Room
12:46 P.M. EDT
MR. FLEISCHER: Good afternoon. Let me give you a report on the President's
day, then I have several announcements pertaining to some meetings and
visits. The President this morning spoke with Bangladeshi Prime Minister Zia.
The President congratulated the Prime Minister on her election victory, and
thanked her for supporting the global coalition against terrorism. He also
conveyed condolences to Prime Minister Zia over the loss of the many Bangladeshi
citizens at the World Trade Center. The President stressed the importance of
showing respect for the Muslim faith in America, as well as around the world.
The President also spoke to Tanzania President Mkapa this morning. The President
thanked President Mkapa for his support of the anti-terrorism coalition, and
acknowledged the common work of the United States and Tanzania in the terrorism
fight since the bombing of the embassy in Dar es Salaam in 1998. President Mkapa
stated that Tanzanians fully support the coalition.
The President convened a meeting of the National Security Council this morning.
He also traveled to the State Department to participate in a forum on the
African Growth and Opportunity Act. This was a forum designed to promote trade
with sub-Saharan African nations and the United States, as a result of
legislation that the President signed earlier this year, that has led to an
increase in trade by some 17 percent compared to last year with sub-Saharan
Africa, something the President thinks is very important for the development of
the African continent.
The President also this afternoon at 2:00 p.m. will convene a meeting of the
Homeland Security Council. And at that meeting, the President is going to
announce creation of a foreign terrorist tracking task force. The purpose of
this is to have a way for the agencies to work together to prevent aliens who
commit or support terror from entering the United States. The President will
also direct these agencies to work together to locate, detain, prosecute or
deport any aliens who may already be here. So this will be stepped-up
enforcement.
Several announcements. President Bush will welcome President Abdelaziz
Bouteflika to the White House on November 5th. That's the President of Algeria.
The President also -- I have an announcement concerning Japan -- welcomes
Japan's actions today to provide forces for surveillance, transport and other
support short of direct combat operations in the war on terrorism. Japan is
already playing an active role in diplomacy, information sharing and
humanitarian assistance. This newest contribution demonstrates the enduring
strength of the U.S.-Japanese relationship.
Four more. President Bush will travel to New York to attend the general debate
of the United Nations General Assembly on November 10th through 11th. The
General Debate was postponed from September due to the terrorist attacks. While
in New York, the President will deliver a speech to the United Nations, attend a
lunch hosted by Secretary General Annan, and host a number of meetings with
world leaders. One of those meetings with world leaders will include President Musharraf of Pakistan, who will meet with the President on November 10th, while
the two are up in New York.
And in an update on some activities at the agencies dealing with the
consequences of the terrorist act, and actions that will be taken to help
America regain its footing and normalcy. Secretary Evans this morning hosted the
first meeting of what's called the Tourist Policy Council. It's the first
meeting since 1997. Secretaries of Transportation, Labor, Interior and HUD,
along with the Small Business Administration and the Immigration and Natural
Services attended. The reestablishment of this commission follows
recommendations made by the travel and tourism industry to the White House
following the attacks on September 11th, as a way to help the travel and the
tourism industry recover.
Secretary O'Neill, at the Department of Treasury today, addressed a special
session of what's called the Financial Action Task Force. That's a group of 29
nations that work together to develop guidelines for money laundering around the
world. The Secretary encouraged the task force to devote its experience to
disrupt the misuse of the international financial system by terrorists and those
who channel funds to them.
In his remarks, the Secretary suggested three goals: one, the establishment of
international standards for combatting terrorist financing; two, to ensure that
not only task force members, but all countries come into compliance with the
standards; and, three, that regular reports be issued on the success in
identifying taking action against terrorist financing.
To date, more than 150 countries are cooperating in the financial war against
terrorism. More than 80 blocking orders have been issued by various nations; $24
million has been blocked.
And I'm more than happy to take questions. Ron Fournier.
Q Despite the previous briefing, there's still some confusion over the cases we
have today. Can you tell us what you know about the identification of anthrax on
the Supreme Court building, where it was found and how much of it. The Cohen
Building, where exactly is that? What agency has authority over it? And tell us
what you know about what was found and how much was found?
MR. FLEISCHER: The information from Health and Human Services, to the best of my
knowledge, was obtained today. It's a preliminary test result, and so the
Department of Health and Human Services is going to continue to review what they
have found. It's a preliminary positive. Additional tests are being done over
there.
Q It's Cohen?
MR. FLEISCHER: That's correct. The Cohen Building is the Department of Health
and Human Services.
Q Is that the mail room?
MR. FLEISCHER: I do not recall if Secretary Thompson indicated it was mail room
or some other facility. I do believe it was the mail room, however.
The Supreme Court, as you know, was a remote facility that was found at the
Supreme Court. They have a remote mail processing center. And your third
question?
Q There are reports of -- the Supreme Court, that was actually found in the
building, I assume. You haven't been brought up to date on that yet?
MR. FLEISCHER: I've not heard those reports.
Q What about the State Department?
MR. FLEISCHER: The State Department, I would refer you to State to get
additional details on that. My understanding is it involved mail that was
received at a remote facility across the street from the State Department that
was brought into the State Department, into the mail rooms at the State
Department.
Q Ari, so it was contaminated mail that was brought into the mail room of the
State Department?
MR. FLEISCHER: That appears to be what it is. That's correct, Randy. Yes, Secret
Service knew about that prior to the President going over there. It did not pose
any problem for the President or his traveling party.
Q Prior to September 10th, did the U.S., either through administration officials
or intermediaries, have any discussions with Taliban representatives about
turning over Osama bin Laden for trial?
MR. FLEISCHER: Terry, the only reports I'm aware of -- and you may want to check
deeper with the State Department because when it comes to diplomatic
communications with other entities they would have more information -- but the
only one I'm aware of, it was a matter of routine for the United States, working
through Pakistan, to talk to the Taliban about the conditions of the Americans
who were held in Afghanistan for preaching Christianity. There have been
contacts on that. Anything beyond that, I do not know.
Q So, as far as you know, as part of those contacts there was no discussion
about turning over bin Laden?
MR. FLEISCHER: No, I'm referring you to State, because that's the only
information I have on the topic.
Q Ari, is it the administration's belief that there is at least one more letter
out there somewhere that's causing a lot of this contamination?
MR. FLEISCHER: It's a possibility. I wouldn't characterize anything as the
President's belief or not. One of the things the President has stressed is to
pursue the facts wherever they may take us, and then to inform people. But,
clearly, that is a theory that investigators have, that it may be more than one
letter.
Q Ari, I want to ask you -- the Cohen Building has two departments in it. It has
the Health and Human Services on one side, and it's got the Voice of America and
WorldNet Television on the other side. Are you saying that the mail room of the
Health and Human Services --
MR. FLEISCHER: I'm saying that the Secretary of Health and Human Services
informed me about it immediately prior to Governor Ridge's briefing, so
information is on its way in. And I'm sure the Department will have additional
information with specifics as soon as it's available.
Q Ari, can you give us any more specifics on this task force, exactly if you're
moving to restrict immigration in some way?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, it's designed to learn some of the lessons about what
happened on September 11th, in which, obviously, aliens entered the United
States for the purpose of engaging in terrorism. And so the task force is going
to work with the various agencies that are involved to try to find that rightful
balance between America remaining a nation that is open and welcoming to
immigrants, while making certain that terrorists are not able to take advantage
of our openness and the fact that we are and must remain a free society, and
enter the country. That's the purpose.
Q What kind of restrictions could we see in the future?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, they're going to be working on a series of recommendations.
The Governor will be announcing, along with the President, the creation of this
task force today, and you'll just have to wait and see what the task force
specifically comes up with.
Q In view of the nation's plight, is the President really supporting rebates to
the tune of billions of dollars for the biggest corporations in this country?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, I'm not sure that I would characterize what is pending on
the Hill in that exact manner. The President has proposed an economic stimulus
plan that includes helping businesses so they don't get penalized for saving and
investment in new plants and new equipment. And as you know, the tax code right
now has a perverse incentive that punishes companies that invest in new plants
and equipment. It's called the Corporate Alternative Minimum Tax. And as a
result of the President's --
Q So he is supporting billions in rebates for these corporations?
MR. FLEISCHER: The President's proposal dealt with it on a prospective basis.
Q Ari, for a President who says he does not like the issue of profiling, and he
stood next to Muslim Americans and Arab Americans -- doesn't this immigration
task force somewhat promote the idea of profiling?
MR. FLEISCHER: No, not at all. It promotes the idea of catching terrorists. And
that will be the goal of this task force, to make certain that terrorists are
not able to enter our country.
You know, our country has had successes catching terrorists. I would refer you
to the Millennium Project, where terrorists tried to infiltrate to take action
domestically against the United States and its citizens on New Year's Eve 1999,
turning the corner to 2000. The government was successful in catching people. On
September 11th, obviously attacks got through. It's very important for the
American people that the government dedicate the proper amount of resources and
the proper diligence, while maintaining our open policies as a nation, as we
move forward. And that's the purpose.
Q A follow-up to that. We keep hearing about this millennium -- how things were
thwarted. Could you give a specific example of what was thwarted? Because many
people are saying that it was basically nothing happened, there was
just --
MR. FLEISCHER: Exactly.
Q I mean, nothing happened because nothing was going to happen. And the federal
government is saying it was thwarted. What was thwarted?
MR. FLEISCHER: Let me, on that, refer you to the FBI -- will be more than happy
to give you the details of what it was.
Q Ari, does the President this week have any plans on meeting with any of the
postal workers here, in New Jersey, in New York? He's met with SES people and
other people --
MR. FLEISCHER: All I can say is we'll keep you advised of his schedule.
Q Ari, on the task force, is the goal of the task force to apply a tighter
screening, to take enforcement action, or just to make recommendations on what
to do?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, the task force is getting created today. And so as the task
force meets and comes out with its recommendations, I wouldn't be surprised to
see if it's a series of both type things. It will be some concrete actions that
agencies can take unilaterally. There may be legislative proposals that they
suggest to the Congress. I think it would be likely to be some combination of
the both. It just depends on what recommendations they come up with.
Q Do you have any feeling for how serious this problem is? I mean, they talked
to, what, 500 people in this investigation. Do you feel like those 500 people
are linked to terrorism and maybe shouldn't be here, or is it just, say, the 19
that were involved?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, it is a problem in that we are an open society, and the
President is determined to make certain we remain an open society, and he wants
to make certain that we are a society that continues to welcome immigrants. But
there's a balance that must be found, while welcoming immigrants, because they
strengthen our country, and always have, making certain that we make sure that
any loopholes are closed so that people who would do harm to the United States,
who are on known terrorist lists, for example, are not allowed into the country.
Q When you said a minute ago that the President's proposals on economic -- tax
breaks for corporations dealt with them on a prospective basis, does that mean
he does not support the proposals on the Hill to give retroactive tax breaks?
And I have a follow to that.
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, I think it's all going to depend on what comes out in the
final mixture of the conference committee. I don't think the President is
prepared, at this point, to go down every ticker of the proposals that are on
the Hill. As you know, they all get lumped together into one big package. And
presidents don't have line-item vetoes. They have to look at a package in its
entirety. And that's what the President looks forward to doing.
But the point is that the President strongly supports, this fall, enactment of
legislation that will help get the economy moving again. This is a very
important economic week for the country. A series of reports are going to come
out this week on the gross domestic product for the third quarter, the
preliminary estimate of it. There will be additional information on Friday about
unemployment for the nation.
And the President does not think that Congress should go home without addressing
fixing our economy and giving it a boost, so people don't lose their jobs, and
providing that stimulus.
Q And, secondly, on that front, how confident is the President that giving money
to corporations will help get the economy going, when he, himself, has
identified demand as one of the problems? He's out there telling us to go spend
money --
MR. FLEISCHER: First of all, it's not a question of giving money to anybody.
Taxes in this country are made by the people who earn them. And so they send
their money into the government. And when the government gives it back, that's
letting people keep the money that they themselves made, whether they are a
corporation, a small business, and individual.
And the package the President sent up to the Congress, after some $55 billion
worth of spending was done by Congress, with the President's support, now the
President has proposed a package of a similar number that would focus on tax
cuts, including tax cuts for low to middle income people who don't pay income
taxes, but who do pay payroll taxes. That would accelerate some of the income
tax rate cuts that were scheduled for 2006 and 2004 to go into effect faster, as
well as help the businesses. Because let me remind you that when businesses buy
plant and equipment, that helps create jobs for the people who make that plant
and equipment.
Q But is there any evidence that they'll do that, given that consumers aren't
buying at the level the President desires?
MR. FLEISCHER: It's always a combination of both. And that's why the President's
plan helps to stimulate demand by giving individuals tax rate reductions, while
helping businesses, so they have incentives to invest in new plant and new
equipment, and thereby hire workers.
Q On the foreign terrorist tracking task force, what are the lines of authority
there? Who is going to chair that? What will Governor Ridge's role be in that?
MR. FLEISCHER: There will be a fact sheet distributed at the time of the
announcement, and that will answer all the questions. I don't have it with me.
Q If I could follow on that, Ari. You pointed out that the government was able
to stop a series of incidents over the millennium. I'm wondering if the goal of
foreign terrorist tracking task force might be to deal with immigration policy
that -- for example, Mohammed Atta, we understand, could have been denied entry
into the country. Would you expect recommendations that concern immigration
policy in addition to dealing with people we already suspect are terrorists?
Presumably, we have the laws to do that.
MR. FLEISCHER: Their charge is to focus on terrorists. And, of course, they will
do so with an overview of the fact that the nation must remain a country that is
welcoming to immigrants and is an open society.
We, historically, have benefitted in fighting wars from the work that immigrants
have done for our country. And so the President is very cognizant of that, and
the President wants to make sure that as we move to make certain terrorists
don't enter the country and that if any terrorists are found here, we're able to
take proper action. He wants that done in the context of being a nation that
continues to be open.
Q So you would not expect recommendations that deal with immigration policy?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, we'll just have to wait and see what they do, Wendell.
Q Ari, on that point, Governor Ridge told us a few moments ago that all options
should be on the table and when talking broadly about immigration, he didn't in
any way, discourage us from thinking that student visas, political asylum, some
other means of access to this country through the immigration system might very
well be a big part of what the task force considers and makes changes to.
MR. FLEISCHER: Sure. As I indicated, we'll just have to see what the task force
comes up with.
Q Is the President generally concerned about misuse or the improper use of
student visas, political asylum, other means of access to the country where
people overstay their legal --
MR. FLEISCHER: The President is concerned about any which way that somebody
could come into this nation as a terrorist and commit terrorist acts, regardless
of what way they're able to slip in.
Q Is the White House dealing with the airlines in terms of, there have been so
many instances in this country where, if you have dark skin and you're on a
plane, you could be ejected because the stewardess doesn't take a liking to you.
So many. What are you doing about that?
MR. FLEISCHER: Helen, I think there is no question that the President has made a
determined effort from day one when he visited a mosque to remind the American
people about the need to remain an open and tolerant society.
As I indicated before, many people who have helped us to win wars we've fought
before were immigrants to this nation. And they are just as American as
everybody else who has been in this nation maybe one day, or one generation, or
five generations longer than they have. So it's always a question of balance.
Q Is there a contact with the airlines to put a halt to this?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think everybody has heard the President's message. And let me
remind you, too, that the government has prosecuted people who, in the mailing
of anthrax, conduct hoaxes, and I'm not aware of anybody saying that we're not
going after people because of one background of somebody. That is a broad
effort. Anybody who breaks the laws of this country needs to be found and needs
to be punished. And that's the President's approach.
Q Laura Bush has said recently that she was offered and refused vaccines and
precautionary antibiotics for bioterrorism. Given her openness, can you tell us
yet whether the President has been offered any of these?
MR. FLEISCHER: I'm not going to go beyond anything the President indicated last
week.
Q Ari, on the task force, how soon does the President want the recommendations?
And will there be any policy -- will there be an interim policy while he awaits
the recommendations?
MR. FLEISCHER: I've not heard a specific definition on it. That may come out in
the fact sheet. And so the event will be -- that's a pool event at the bottom.
And so the press will have access to the meeting and access to all that
information. Also can't give it all out now, because otherwise you might not
come to the event. So it's a little after 2:00 p.m.
Q Does the President have any plans to travel to New York in the next 48 hours?
MR. FLEISCHER: As always, we will keep you posted of the President's travels.
And I just do want to remind you that the White House will be forthcoming,
provide travel information. And until then, I have not given any indications.
Q Are there any special or growing concerns about Pakistan? Musharraf has pushed
us to stop bombing by Ramadan. We know that there are people amassed on the
border, saying they want to go in and help the Taliban. As well there are
questions about the Pakistani intelligence service, and have they been helping
the Taliban. Are there growing concerns here, or anything special that you're
doing as it relates to Pakistan, to keep them in the coalition?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, President Bush has always been working very closely, since
the beginning of this, with President Musharraf. And the Secretary has been in
touch -- Secretary Powell has been in regular touch. The President will continue
to have close cooperation with Pakistan, to work with them as we together fight
terrorism. It's a volatile region, of course, and the stability of the region is
very important. And that's always foremost in the minds of the planners, and of
the people who are conducting the policies.
Q Ari, is the administration at all looking into the possibility that some
industries, some companies have taken advantage of the current economic climate
to fatten the number of people they are laying off?
MR. FLEISCHER: Actually, if you heard in the President's remarks last week in
the East Room, I think the President went out of his room, I think the President
went out of his way to note that there were several industries that have kept
people working. And they serve as examples to other industries who are able to
keep people on the payroll at this time of difficult economic circumstances
throughout the country.
The President recognizes that the private sector has a right to make hiring and
firing decisions. But the President did compliment the auto industry for the
actions that they are taking.
Q Has the administration looked into the possibility of price gouging in the
fuel situation earlier this year? Does it have any plans to look into the
possibility of what I posed there, that some companies are taking advantage of
this to cut their payrolls?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, price gouging is an entirely different topic, and that
remains an issue that the United States government has a series of agencies set
up to make certain that does not occur. It's notable then, despite the fact that
we do have volatility in the Middle East, the price of oil has come down.
Q But what about the employment rolls? Is there any effort to see --
MR. FLEISCHER: I would refer you to what the President said last week. The
President expressed himself very clearly, complimenting those industries that
have taken those steps. But again, in this country, the government is not the
entity that does all the hiring and firing.
Q Well, do you think any companies have taken advantage of this to cut their job
rolls?
MR. FLEISCHER: Again, I'll just refer you to what the President said last week.
I think he addressed it.
Q The Japanese parliament passed legislation to authorize the dispatch of the
self-defense forces overseas, to provide logistical support for the U.S.
military.
MR. FLEISCHER: Right.
Q Any reaction from the White House? Does the President believe that Japan's
non-combat action would make any difference in this military campaign?
MR. FLEISCHER: You must have had a very important meeting, because I addressed
that at the top of my briefing, in a statement.
Q Ari, it is likely that the economic stimulus bill in the Senate is going to
look quite different from the bill -- the House. I'm wondering if the President
has laid out any realistic markers yet that would guide a conference committee
beyond the sort of general statements that you've been making the last few days?
MR. FLEISCHER: What I think you're seeing is a healthy process working. This is
the way our system works. The House passes legislation, the Senate passes
legislation, as is their prerogative to do. And the President looks forward to
the Senate passing it; he hopes they will.
There is a possibility they won't do it this fall, and the President thinks that
would be a very bad mistake that would hurt workers at a time they need help. So
--
Q He sure is not going to be a passive observer,
though --
MR. FLEISCHER: I think what's important is that bill make it to conference. That
typically is the way that presidents have been able to work the closest and work
the best with the Congress. But the first step is for the Senate to pass it.
The President clearly did lay out the four components of what he believes a
stimulus package should be; I walked you through them earlier in the briefing.
So, he has laid out the parameters, he has laid out his principles with several
specifics, four specifics, and now it's up to the Senate to act.
Q Ari, prior to September 11th, the President appeared to be leaning to
liberalize the immigration laws, particularly in regard to establishment of the
guest worker program of Mexico. Is that dead now, and particularly in light of
current atmosphere?
MR. FLEISCHER: No, it's not dead. But, clearly, the two principal people who
were involved in drafting the new immigration policy to Mexico are Attorney
General Ashcroft and Secretary of State Colin Powell. And as a result of the war
and as a result of the anthrax and other duties that both of them have, it has
not moved at the pace the President had hoped it would move, and I think that's
understandable.
Q Ari, on the truck issue, since September we haven't heard really very much
about what the President wants to do on Mexican trucks coming into the country,
full operations by January.
MR. FLEISCHER: The President's position on allowing Mexican trucks into the
country remains the same as it was, that it's important for the trucks to be
operating safely in the United States, for them to enter legally, and for the
government to hire additional inspectors on the borders. So that way, they can
inspect the trucks.
Q Would you look at some kind of a phase-in now rather than just trying to get
--
MR. FLEISCHER: The action now is in the Congress, and the President is hoping
that Congress will take action.
Q Ari, as we head into the flu season, can you tell us exactly what the
administration wants the American people to do?
On Friday, Secretary Thompson said that they didn't want younger, healthier
people running out to get the flu vaccine in order to avoid confusing symptoms
with anthrax.
And over the weekend there were reports that they did want everyone to get
vaccinated, even more urgently than in years past. There's some confusion here.
Can you tell us exactly what the administration wants --
MR. FLEISCHER: Those judgments will be made by the appropriate health officials
and people working with their individual doctors. That's not the type of
statement you should expect to come from the White House podium.
Q Ari, last week, the President said he wanted to see checks mailed to people
who didn't get one this summer. The IRS Commissioner says, that's impossible. Is
the President still committed to that, or is he willing to wait several months
or have that money rolled over into tax refunds next year?
MR. FLEISCHER: The point the President is making is, he believes it is important
to get tax relief to low- to middle-income people, people who do not pay income
taxes, but who do pay payroll taxes. And the President has offered that in the
proposal that he has sent up to the Hill. He believes that that will -- that
rebate value of that check will have a stimulative effect on the economy, just
as it did for upper-income workers. But the President is flexible on the exact
means by which that can be accomplished.
Q Ari, the task force is focused on foreign non-citizens -- immigration and
whatnot. Does this mean that you believe that the source of these attacks --
say, anthrax attacks -- are foreign and not domestic? And what will the
administration do about, say, homegrown terrorists, like white supremacy groups,
et cetera?
MR. FLEISCHER: Right. No, it's no indication one way or another about whether
the President thinks the anthrax attacks are foreign or domestic. As you've
heard repeatedly, the government has not been able to rule out or in whether the
source is domestic or foreign.
But the President does know that the terrorists have entered our country
illegally, and in some cases legally. And he wants to make certain that if
somebody is a known terrorist, they should not get access to American soil.
Q How about the homegrown groups, Ari, the white supremacists and what not? Are
they also under the domain of this tax force, or --
MR. FLEISCHER: No, the task force deals with immigration. But, clearly, the FBI,
in its efforts to target and to find and to prosecute, to arrest those who are
responsible, or the person who is responsible for the anthrax attacks, are
looking everywhere domestically, as well as internationally. And whoever did it,
the President believes will get arrested for murder, and will be tried.
Q Ari, two of the parameters the President set for the stimulus package also
seem to be agreed upon by Senator Daschle. Both believe that any final package
should be short-term, and should be stimulative.
Two specific provisions in the House bill, capital gains provision and the
rebate for AMT credit have been criticized for not meeting those tests. Would
the President sign a bill that contains those two provisions, even if they're
questionable in terms of meeting the test
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, the first task is to get this bill to the conference. And
the President wants to make sure that the Senate takes action. Obviously,
nothing can get to Congress and there can be no stimulus to help the economy if
the Senate doesn't take action. So that must come first, and then the President
will work with the Congress. You know what his four principles, his four
specifics are. The President would like those to be what he can sign. But he
also recognizes that Congress doesn't do everything Presidents say.
Q Also, on the anthrax issue.
MR. FLEISCHER: On the which issue?
Q The anthrax issue.
MR. FLEISCHER: Yes.
Q Given how it's considered one of the most menacing public health issues we've
had in the United States, why has the Surgeon General not had a more prominent
role in addressing this issue?
MR. FLEISCHER: I believe the Surgeon General has had a prominent role. I've seen
him on several of the TV shows. There have been many people who have been
playing a big role, including the director of the NIH was on this weekend, as
well. So I think the government is calling on the advice and the expertise of a
host of people.
Q Treasury Secretary O'Neill said Friday that the economy has almost gotten back
to where it was on September 10th, though the economic data was mixed. And he
said it was poised to begin a rebound in the first quarter of 2002. Does the
President share that rather optimistic attitude about where the economy is right
now? And, if so, what's the need for a stimulus?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, Major, the President makes no such predictions, because the
President is not an economist. But there is a growing body of evidence in the
economic world that would have previously been called a U-shaped recovery, which
kind of comes down not as low -- lack of economic growth, and then it takes its
time to come back up, may indeed be a V-shape, where it goes down to even a
lower amount of growth, and then it comes back up sharper and faster. There's a
growing body of economists who believe that may be the case. But, again, the
White House doesn't engage in the prediction business.
Q Can I just follow-up, Ari? There will be an announcement shortly here about
the 2001 fiscal budget surplus, estimated to be down about $30 billion. Mitch
Daniels has said next year we're going to be in real, unified deficits. How big
a deficit problem does this country face, considering all the things that have
to be done, in federal spending, dealing with September 11th?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think it's too soon to say. I think it's very likely that the
information released later today about the size of the surplus for 2001 is going
to show that the government has enjoyed the second-largest surplus in the
history of this country. It is less than it was in 2000, but it still remains
the second-largest ever.
Clearly, the President wants to have growth. Growth, the President believes, is
the answer to building surpluses back up. The President knows that an economy
that's growing at 3 percent, 4 percent, 5 percent a year fills the coffers of
the Treasury Department; and that's how you get out of any deficits and back
into surpluses if deficits emerge.
Q Ari, back on immigration. So are you going to move on a two-tracks here --
moving to liberalize immigration for Mexico, but restricting it in other ways,
or are you just going to let the earlier effort sort of go on the back burner
for a while?
MR. FLEISCHER: Again, I think it's just too soon to say. The President hasn't
even announced the task force yet. And so -- I wanted to share it with you; he
hasn't even announced it yet. I think you just have to let the task force get up
and running.
Q Is the President going to meet with Chairman Arafat in New York when he goes
to New York?
MR. FLEISCHER: As always, if we have anything to announce, we'll let you know.
Q And then a follow-up on that. Foreign Minister Peres said that the United
States changed its demand that Israel withdraw from the Sector A, Zone A areas
immediately to -- soon, because Foreign Minister Peres says he talked to the
President, said Israel had no intention of staying. Is that an accurate
description of what happened?
MR. FLEISCHER: Let me just characterize to you what the President's response is
to Israel's withdrawal. The President believes that it's a step in the right
direction, and he would like to see it completed in its entirety. He also
condemns the Palestinian Islamic Jihad for their attack in Hadera yesterday, and
he does note that the Palestinian Authority did condemn that attack.
The President again calls on Chairman Arafat to make a 100 percent effort to
reduce the violence in the Middle East.
Q But what happened to the demand that Israel withdraw immediately?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think I've addressed the question in the totality.
Q Ari, let me see if I can get you to quantify something. Is this administration
any closer to identifying the source of the anthrax or who was responsible for
sending it? Have you come any closer to making that identification than you were
back when the very first case became apparent in early October?
MR. FLEISCHER: I don't know how to quantify that, John. I mean, this is an
investigative matter. And as the investigators pursue their leads and pore
through their evidence, they make judgments. And I suppose like in any
investigation, it's fair to say that some days they make steps forward, some
days they're not able to make steps, some days they may have steps that don't go
forward. So I think it's just an investigative matter, and the right people are
doing the investigating.
Q Do you have any better understanding of where it came from or who was
responsible than you did back in early October?
MR. FLEISCHER: My statement on Friday, that the government still does not know
whether the source is domestic or foreign, stands.
Q Ari, back to the subject of immigration. Throughout this months of the
presidency, George W. Bush has always said that he wants legal immigration to
proceed. I'm asking if, after the events of September 11th, is there a delay in
processing either residency or citizenship, or will this continue at the same
pace the President wanted before --
MR. FLEISCHER: Yes, I don't know the answer to that. If you're asking how the
INS is processing its forms, you really need to ask them.
Q Does the President remain committed to legal immigration --
MR. FLEISCHER: That's what I said.
Q Let me follow that, Ari. You said a minute ago that immigrants have offered as
much to this country as any other Americans. But we're not talking at this point
about immigrants, we're not talking about Americans. We're talking about
resident aliens, some legal and some not. Do you still not draw a distinction
between those two groups?
MR. FLEISCHER: The President's point is that if anybody is in this country as a
result of our immigration policies that are engaged in terrorist attacks or came
here for the purpose of engaging in terrorism, he knows that the American people
want those people to be caught before they can take another terrorist attack.
THE PRESS: Thank you.
END 1:20 P.M. EST