For Immediate Release Office of the Press Secretary October 31, 2001
President Discusses Economic Stimulus with National Association of Manufacturers Presidential Hall Dwight D. Eisenhower Executive Office Building
View the President's Remarks Listen to the President's Remarks 11:13 A.M. EST THE PRESIDENT: Thank you all. Welcome. Nice to see everybody. Thank you very much. I've just finished icing down my arm. (Laughter.) Today there's some news out on our economy, and it confirms that the events of September the 11th really shocked the nation. It affected our work force, and affected our business base. The Gross Domestic Product for the third quarter was negative. People are having tough times in America. People are losing their jobs. And I'm deeply concerned about that, and I know you are, as well. Consumer confidence is down. After all, we're at war, and for the first time in our nation's history, part of the battlefront is here at home. Shipments, particularly in the manufacturing sector, declined dramatically in recent months. And it's time for our government to act in a positive and constructive way. The Congress needs to pass a stimulus package and get it to my desk before the end of November. I had breakfast today with the Speaker and Minority Leader, Majority Leader Daschle and Senator Lott -- all five of us agreed that we need to work together to get a package; that we've got to put aside political differences and act swiftly and strongly on behalf of the American worker and the American business person. And so my call to Congress is: Get to work and get something done. The American people expect us to do just that. (Applause.) I want to thank Paul O'Neill for being here. He is leading the charge on Capitol Hill for a common-sense economic stimulus package. He brings a lot of experience to the job. After all, he was a manufacturer at one time. He knows the struggles that you go through. And, like me, he hurts with the workers who aren't finding work these days. And I appreciate Christie Todd being here, as well. One of the smartest things I've done is to tap some of my former governor colleagues and ask them to come to the government. I tapped a great one when I tapped Christie Todd Whitman. She brings a lot of sense and a good view of our environmental policy. And the American people are proud of the job she's doing, and so am I. Thank you for both being here. I also want to thank Tim very much for his friendship and his introduction. I didn't realize you were quite so eloquent. (Laughter.) You must be taking speech lessons. (Laughter.) I want to thank Don Wainwright, as well, and of course, Jerry Jasinowski for his friendship and support. I -- the American people know that we have acted quickly in terms of this attack that has taken place, and we've done so on the domestic front in quick order. Both Republicans and Democrats decided to spend a considerable sum of money to address the country's needs. We've allocated $55 billion, and it didn't take long to spend it, I might add. A big chunk of that is going to go to make sure we defend our country, make sure our Defense Department is bolstered during this war. A significant amount of money went to help New York City recover, as it should. We want New York City to be on her feet. It's an important symbol for the world that New York City be strong and vibrant. We spent a considerable amount of money for airplane security. My attitude was that the most directly affected industry was the airline industry and, therefore, we had to spend money to make sure the airlines survived, and make sure there was loan money, and make sure that the consumer realized that the government was acting in a positive way to bring security to our airports. And the first act we took was to empower governors to say, bring your guard to the gates. Put troops so that people will see a visible presence. And we started to increase the air marshals. And Congress is now working on an airport security bill, and I hope I am able to sign that pretty quickly, too. But we are taking action. And we need to spend money on helping workers who were -- lost their job as a result of the attack of September the 11th. I believe we need to expend -- extend and expand that unemployment benefits to those workers. And I know we need to expand what they call national emergency grants, which will give governors the latitude to take federal monies, and apply that money to workers -- special workers' needs, such as health care benefits, to make sure that any laid off worker can have -- be able to pay the premiums of their health care plans. And so there will be -- there's more need. But I caution the Congress not to overspend. The temptation is to fund everybody's good idea. And my attitude is that our money ought to be focused and effective; the spending ought to be focused. And we ought to ask the question, is this effective spending. We need to make sure that when we spend there's a strategy and a reason. And so I look forward to working with the appropriators to be responsible about how we spend taxpayers' money, particularly as we run up to what I hope is a recess around the Thanksgiving period. And we also ought to make sure that we offset any spending with tax relief; that the way to have a balanced stimulus package is to recognize we've spent a considerable amount of money up to date, and we need to spend some more for our workers, but we ought to offset that with tax relief. And I have laid out some ideas for Congress to consider. One the one hand, we've got to make sure that we bolster consumer demand by both accelerating the tax cuts that now exist, as well as providing rebates for non-taxpayers, but who filed. In other words, there are some people who didn't get rebates last year -- generally, low-income people -- that filed an income tax return, but they didn't pay tax, and they ought to get a rebate. And Congress ought to act as quickly as possible to get that money into people's hands as quickly as possible to bolster demand. And then we've got to make sure our tax relief encourages investment, encourages the flow of capital. And therefore, I think we need to reform the alternative minimum tax on corporate America, so corporate America doesn't have to get penalized during times of declining earnings -- that doesn't make any sense to do that -- as well as encourage investment in new plant and equipment. The House has passed some elements of that plan, and the Senate needs to act. And any differences we can work out in conference. But time is of the essence. As I mentioned, the leadership is prepared to spend the time necessary to get a good package out, and I'm grateful for that. And I hope the bill writers get moving. That's what the American people expect. I also want the Congress to know that there is more to helping our economy grow than just tax relief, or just spending. And there's two items I want to briefly touch on -- one is an energy plan. Our nation needs an energy plan -- an energy plan that encourages conservation and encourages exploration. And I believe we can do both in a responsible way. And we need to modernize the infrastructure that develops energy from point A to point B, from plant to consumer. We need to get after it. It is in our national interest that we have an energy plan, one designed to make us less reliant upon foreign sources of energy. (Applause.) And, as Tim mentioned, I need to have what's called trade promotion authority. I need to be able to negotiate trade agreements with nations who want to trade with America. The Congress can vote the trade agreement down if they don't like it. But we need to be aggressive when it comes to opening up markets and taking advantage of opportunities around the world. This nation should not stand on the sidelines when it comes to free trade. We must be confident. People who build walls around America aren't confident in America. They're not confident in American workers; they're not confident in American businesses. I'm confident in America's ability to compete. I want to tear walls down. I want to make it easier for the world to trade in freedom. I think it's good for American workers that we trade. I think it's good for American business that we trade. And I know it's good for the spread of American values if we trade freely around the world. (Applause.) And so, I ask the Congress to be confident as we approach these big issues; be confident in the ability of the American people; be confident in the ability of the entrepreneur to succeed; be confident in our future of the country. And that's exactly the way I feel. This is a very unusual period in American history, obviously. We've never been attacked like this before. We're still being attacked. Our heart goes out to anybody who suffers in America. And so, we're bolstering our homeland defense. We're disrupting and denying anybody who wants to harm the American people. We spend hours tracking down every possible lead of somebody who would come into this country or who might be burrowed in this country, trying to hurt any American. And I'm proud of our law enforcement officials, who work nonstop, around the clock, taking every single lead and pursuing it to its end. Yesterday -- or a couple of days ago, I put the country on alert for a reason; that, on the one hand, while we will go about our business of going to World Series games or shopping or traveling to Washington, D.C., I want our law enforcement officials to know we had some information that made it necessary for us to protect the United States assets, to protect those areas that might be vulnerable. And that's exactly what's taking place today. And we're also fighting a war overseas, with the purpose of hunting down the evildoers and bringing them to justice. And I'm patient and I'm focused, and I will not yield. We must win. We have no other choice, for our children and our grandchildren, that we bring any terrorist to justice and hold those nations who harbor them -- which harbor them, or feed them, or clothe them to justice, as well. And the United States will prevail. (Applause.) People ask me about the economy. They say, are you worried? I say, I'm worried any time anybody loses a job. But in the long term, I'm optimistic about the U.S. economy. We've got good tax policy. We've got low interest rates. We've got the best workers in the world. We've got an entrepreneurial spirit that is infectious and strong, and alive and well. We are the best place to do business in the entire globe. And that hadn't changed. But I'm optimistic for another reason. I'm optimistic because the spirit of this country is incredibly strong. This is a fabulous nation. The evil ones thought they could affect the spirit of America, but it's had an opposite effect. Our country is patient; our country is resolved; our country is united, regardless of our religion, regardless of where we live, regardless of our political party. We're united behind the fact that we must rise to this occasion. And rise we will. We will plant that flag of freedom forever, by winning the war against terrorism, by rallying our economy, and by keeping strong and adhering to the values we hold so dear, starting with freedom. (Applause.) I want to thank you all for letting me come by. Thank you for letting me come by. (Laughter.) Keep working hard. Keep working hard. And may God continue to bless America. (Applause.) END 11:28 A.M. EST Return to this article at: /news/releases/2001/10/20011031-1.html
11:13 A.M. EST
THE PRESIDENT: Thank you all. Welcome. Nice to see everybody. Thank you very much. I've just finished icing down my arm. (Laughter.)
Today there's some news out on our economy, and it confirms that the events of September the 11th really shocked the nation. It affected our work force, and affected our business base. The Gross Domestic Product for the third quarter was negative.
People are having tough times in America. People are losing their jobs. And I'm deeply concerned about that, and I know you are, as well. Consumer confidence is down. After all, we're at war, and for the first time in our nation's history, part of the battlefront is here at home.
Shipments, particularly in the manufacturing sector, declined dramatically in recent months. And it's time for our government to act in a positive and constructive way. The Congress needs to pass a stimulus package and get it to my desk before the end of November.
I had breakfast today with the Speaker and Minority Leader, Majority Leader Daschle and Senator Lott -- all five of us agreed that we need to work together to get a package; that we've got to put aside political differences and act swiftly and strongly on behalf of the American worker and the American business person. And so my call to Congress is: Get to work and get something done. The American people expect us to do just that. (Applause.)
I want to thank Paul O'Neill for being here. He is leading the charge on Capitol Hill for a common-sense economic stimulus package. He brings a lot of experience to the job. After all, he was a manufacturer at one time. He knows the struggles that you go through. And, like me, he hurts with the workers who aren't finding work these days.
And I appreciate Christie Todd being here, as well. One of the smartest things I've done is to tap some of my former governor colleagues and ask them to come to the government. I tapped a great one when I tapped Christie Todd Whitman. She brings a lot of sense and a good view of our environmental policy. And the American people are proud of the job she's doing, and so am I. Thank you for both being here.
I also want to thank Tim very much for his friendship and his introduction. I didn't realize you were quite so eloquent. (Laughter.) You must be taking speech lessons. (Laughter.) I want to thank Don Wainwright, as well, and of course, Jerry Jasinowski for his friendship and support.
I -- the American people know that we have acted quickly in terms of this attack that has taken place, and we've done so on the domestic front in quick order. Both Republicans and Democrats decided to spend a considerable sum of money to address the country's needs.
We've allocated $55 billion, and it didn't take long to spend it, I might add. A big chunk of that is going to go to make sure we defend our country, make sure our Defense Department is bolstered during this war. A significant amount of money went to help New York City recover, as it should. We want New York City to be on her feet. It's an important symbol for the world that New York City be strong and vibrant.
We spent a considerable amount of money for airplane security. My attitude was that the most directly affected industry was the airline industry and, therefore, we had to spend money to make sure the airlines survived, and make sure there was loan money, and make sure that the consumer realized that the government was acting in a positive way to bring security to our airports.
And the first act we took was to empower governors to say, bring your guard to the gates. Put troops so that people will see a visible presence. And we started to increase the air marshals. And Congress is now working on an airport security bill, and I hope I am able to sign that pretty quickly, too.
But we are taking action. And we need to spend money on helping workers who were -- lost their job as a result of the attack of September the 11th. I believe we need to expend -- extend and expand that unemployment benefits to those workers. And I know we need to expand what they call national emergency grants, which will give governors the latitude to take federal monies, and apply that money to workers -- special workers' needs, such as health care benefits, to make sure that any laid off worker can have -- be able to pay the premiums of their health care plans.
And so there will be -- there's more need. But I caution the Congress not to overspend. The temptation is to fund everybody's good idea. And my attitude is that our money ought to be focused and effective; the spending ought to be focused. And we ought to ask the question, is this effective spending. We need to make sure that when we spend there's a strategy and a reason.
And so I look forward to working with the appropriators to be responsible about how we spend taxpayers' money, particularly as we run up to what I hope is a recess around the Thanksgiving period. And we also ought to make sure that we offset any spending with tax relief; that the way to have a balanced stimulus package is to recognize we've spent a considerable amount of money up to date, and we need to spend some more for our workers, but we ought to offset that with tax relief. And I have laid out some ideas for Congress to consider.
One the one hand, we've got to make sure that we bolster consumer demand by both accelerating the tax cuts that now exist, as well as providing rebates for non-taxpayers, but who filed. In other words, there are some people who didn't get rebates last year -- generally, low-income people -- that filed an income tax return, but they didn't pay tax, and they ought to get a rebate.
And Congress ought to act as quickly as possible to get that money into people's hands as quickly as possible to bolster demand.
And then we've got to make sure our tax relief encourages investment, encourages the flow of capital. And therefore, I think we need to reform the alternative minimum tax on corporate America, so corporate America doesn't have to get penalized during times of declining earnings -- that doesn't make any sense to do that -- as well as encourage investment in new plant and equipment.
The House has passed some elements of that plan, and the Senate needs to act. And any differences we can work out in conference. But time is of the essence. As I mentioned, the leadership is prepared to spend the time necessary to get a good package out, and I'm grateful for that. And I hope the bill writers get moving. That's what the American people expect.
I also want the Congress to know that there is more to helping our economy grow than just tax relief, or just spending. And there's two items I want to briefly touch on -- one is an energy plan. Our nation needs an energy plan -- an energy plan that encourages conservation and encourages exploration. And I believe we can do both in a responsible way.
And we need to modernize the infrastructure that develops energy from point A to point B, from plant to consumer. We need to get after it. It is in our national interest that we have an energy plan, one designed to make us less reliant upon foreign sources of energy. (Applause.)
And, as Tim mentioned, I need to have what's called trade promotion authority. I need to be able to negotiate trade agreements with nations who want to trade with America. The Congress can vote the trade agreement down if they don't like it. But we need to be aggressive when it comes to opening up markets and taking advantage of opportunities around the world.
This nation should not stand on the sidelines when it comes to free trade. We must be confident. People who build walls around America aren't confident in America. They're not confident in American workers; they're not confident in American businesses. I'm confident in America's ability to compete. I want to tear walls down. I want to make it easier for the world to trade in freedom. I think it's good for American workers that we trade. I think it's good for American business that we trade. And I know it's good for the spread of American values if we trade freely around the world. (Applause.)
And so, I ask the Congress to be confident as we approach these big issues; be confident in the ability of the American people; be confident in the ability of the entrepreneur to succeed; be confident in our future of the country. And that's exactly the way I feel.
This is a very unusual period in American history, obviously. We've never been attacked like this before. We're still being attacked. Our heart goes out to anybody who suffers in America. And so, we're bolstering our homeland defense. We're disrupting and denying anybody who wants to harm the American people. We spend hours tracking down every possible lead of somebody who would come into this country or who might be burrowed in this country, trying to hurt any American. And I'm proud of our law enforcement officials, who work nonstop, around the clock, taking every single lead and pursuing it to its end.
Yesterday -- or a couple of days ago, I put the country on alert for a reason; that, on the one hand, while we will go about our business of going to World Series games or shopping or traveling to Washington, D.C., I want our law enforcement officials to know we had some information that made it necessary for us to protect the United States assets, to protect those areas that might be vulnerable. And that's exactly what's taking place today.
And we're also fighting a war overseas, with the purpose of hunting down the evildoers and bringing them to justice. And I'm patient and I'm focused, and I will not yield. We must win. We have no other choice, for our children and our grandchildren, that we bring any terrorist to justice and hold those nations who harbor them -- which harbor them, or feed them, or clothe them to justice, as well. And the United States will prevail. (Applause.)
People ask me about the economy. They say, are you worried? I say, I'm worried any time anybody loses a job. But in the long term, I'm optimistic about the U.S. economy. We've got good tax policy. We've got low interest rates. We've got the best workers in the world. We've got an entrepreneurial spirit that is infectious and strong, and alive and well. We are the best place to do business in the entire globe. And that hadn't changed.
But I'm optimistic for another reason. I'm optimistic because the spirit of this country is incredibly strong. This is a fabulous nation. The evil ones thought they could affect the spirit of America, but it's had an opposite effect. Our country is patient; our country is resolved; our country is united, regardless of our religion, regardless of where we live, regardless of our political party. We're united behind the fact that we must rise to this occasion. And rise we will. We will plant that flag of freedom forever, by winning the war against terrorism, by rallying our economy, and by keeping strong and adhering to the values we hold so dear, starting with freedom. (Applause.)
I want to thank you all for letting me come by. Thank you for letting me come by. (Laughter.) Keep working hard. Keep working hard. And may God continue to bless America. (Applause.)
END 11:28 A.M. EST
