Revised September 20, 1979
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- Proposed legislation
- Pending bill
- Report (including testimony)
- Enrolled bill
- Views letter
- Submission to OMB
- Purposes of legislative program submission
- Timing of submission to OMB
- Number of copies
- Program content
- Relationship to advice
- Submission to OMB
- Agency scheduling of submissions
- Timing of agency submissions
- Number of copies
- Submission of legislation authorizing the enactment of new budget authority
- Items to be included in agency submissions
- Views letters
- Certain statutory and other requirements and Administration policies
- Drafting service
- Use of "no comment" reports
- OMB action on agency submissions
- Forms of OMB advice
- Agency action on receipt of advice from OMB
- Agency action where prior clearance has not been effected
- Reclearance requirements
- Initial OMB action
- Agency action
- Preparation of enrolled bill letters
- Subsequent OMB action
- Instructions Relating to the Preparation of Agency Legislative Programs
- Instructions for the Preparation and Submission to Congress of Legislative Proposals Authorizing the Enactment of Additional Appropriations or Providing New Budget Authority Outside of Appropriation Acts
- Basic Forms of OMB Advice
September 20, 1979
Transmittal Memorandum No. 1
TO THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND ESTABLISHMENTS
Revision of Circular No. A-19, Revised, Dated July 31,
Legislative Coordination and Clearance
This transmits a revision of Circular No. A-19, Revised, dated July 1972: Legislative Coordination and Clearance.
The attached revision updates the Circular generally and makes explicit several long-standing practices. It does not change the basic aspects of the legislative coordination and clearance requirements and process.
The principal changes are as follows:
- The Circular has been extensively restructured and a table of contents has been added to facilitate its reference use.
- Requirements to identify the effect of legislation on personnel needs have been made explicit (sections 6e(5), 7f(1)(c), 7f(2), and 1Oc(4)(f)).
- Requirements are set forth with respect to section 607 of the Congressional Budqet Act of 1974 dealing with year-ahead requests for authorizing the enactment of new budget authority (section 7e and Attachment B).
- Additions have been made to the list of statutory and other requirements and Administration policies that should be taken into account (section 7h).
- orms of clearance advice given by OMB are set forth and explained (section 8(b) and Attachment C).
- Previous Attachments B, C, and D have been deleted.
TO THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND ESTABLISHMENTS
SUBJECT: Legislative coordination and clearance
1. Purpose. This Circular outlines procedures for the coordination and clearance by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) of agency recommendations on proposed, pending, and enrolled legislation. It also includes instructions on the timing and preparation of agency legislative programs.
3. Background. OMB performs legislative coordination and clearance functions to (a) assist the President in developing a position on legislation, (b) make known the Administration's position on legislation for the guidance of the agencies and information of Congress, (c) assure appropriate consideration of the views of all affected agencies, and (d) assist the President with respect to action on enrolled bills.
4. Coverage. All executive branch agencies (as defined in section 5b) are subject to the provisions of this Circular, except those agencies that are specifically required by law to transmit their legislative proposals, reports, or testimony to the Congress without prior clearance. OMB will, however, honor requests from such agencies for advice on the relationship of particular legislation, reports, or testimony to the program of the President. The municipal government of the District of Columbia is covered to the extent that legislation involves the relationship between it and the Federal Government. Agencies of the legislative and judicial branches are not covered by this Circular.
- Advice. Information transmitted to an agency by
OMB stating the relationship of particular legislation
and reports thereon to the program of the President or
stating the views of OMB as a staff agency for the President
with respect to such legislation and reports.
- Agency. Any executive department or independent
commission, board, bureau, office, agency, Government-owned
or controlled corporation, or other establishment of
the Government, including any regulatory commission or
board and also the municipal government of the District
- Proposed legislation*. A draft bill or any
supporting document (e.g., Speaker letter, section-by-section
analysis, statement of purpose and justification, etc.)
that an agency wishes to present to Congress for its
consideration. Also, any proposal for or endorsement
of Federal legislation included in an agency's annual
or special report or in other written form which an agency
proposes to transmit to Congress, or to any Member or
committee, officer or employee of Congress, or staff
of any committee or Member, or to make available to any
study group, commission, or the public.
- Pending bill. Any bill or resolution that
has been introduced in Congress or any amendment to a
bill or resolution while in committee or when proposed
for House or Senate floor consideration during debate.
Also, any proposal placed before the conferees on a bill
that has passed both Houses.
- Report (including testimony).* Any written
expression of official views prepared by an agency on
a pending bill for (1) transmittal to any committee,
Member, officer or employee of Congress, or staff of
any committee or Member, or (2) presentation as testimony
before a congressional committee. Also, any comment or
recommendation on pending legislation included in an
agency's annual or special report that an agency proposes
to transmit to Congress, or any Member or committee,
or to make available to any study group, commission,
or the public.
- Enrolled bill. A bill or resolution passed
by both Houses of Congress and presented to the President
- Views letter. An agency's written comments provided at the request of OMB on a pending bill or on another agency's proposed legislation, report, or testimony.
- Submission to OMB. Each agency shall prepare and submit to OMB annually its proposed legislative program for the next session of Congress. If an agency has no legislative program, it should submit a statement to this effect.
* The terms "proposed legislation" and "report" do not include materials submitted in justification of appropriation requests or proposals for reorganization plans.
- Purposes of legislative program submission. The essential
purposes for requiring agencies to submit annual legislative
programs are: (1) to assist agency planning for legislative
objectives; (2) to help agencies coordinate their legislative
program with the preparation of their annual budget
submissions to OMB; (3) to give agencies an opportunity
to recommend specific proposals for Presidential endorsement;
and (4) to aid OMB and other staff of the Executive
Office of the President in developing the President's
legislative program, budget, and annual and special
- Timing of submission to OMB. (1) Each agency shall
submit its proposed legislative program to OMB at the
same time as it initially submits its annual budget
request as required by OMB Circular No. A-11. Timely
submission is essential if the programs are to serve
the purposes set forth in section 6b.
(2) Items that are not included in an agency's legislative program and have significant upward budget impact will not be considered after the budget is prepared unless they result from circumstances not foreseeable at the time of final budget decisions.
- Number of copies. Each agency shall furnish 25 copies
of its proposed legislative program to OMB. These copies
will be distributed by OMB within the Executive Office
of the President.
- Program content. Each agency shall prepare its legislative
program in accordance with the instructions in Attachment
A. Agency submissions shall include:
(1) All items of legislation that an agency contemplates proposing to Congress (or actively supporting, if already pending legislation) during the coming session, including proposals to extend expiring laws or repeal provisions of existing laws. These items should be based on policy-level decisions within the agency and should take into account the President's known legislative, budgetary, and other relevant policies. Agencies' proposed legislative programs should identify those items of sufficient importance to be included in the President's legislative program.
(2) A separate list of legislative proposals under active consideration in the agency that are not yet ready for inclusion in its proposed legislative program. For each item in this list, the agency should indicate when it expects to reach a policy-level decision and, specifically, whether it expects to propose the item in time for its consideration for inclusion in the annual budget under preparation.
(3) A separate list of all laws or provisions of law affecting an agency that will expire between the date the program is submitted to OMB and the end of the two following calendar years, whether or not the agency plans to propose their extension.
(4) All items in the submissions that are proposed, or expected to be proposed, for inclusion in the annual budget shall be accompanied by a tabulation showing amounts of budget authority and outlays or other measure of budgetary impact for the budget year and for each of the four succeeding fiscal years. See section 201(a)(5),(6), and (12) of the Budget and Accounting Act, 1921, as amended (31 U.S.C. 11(a)(12)). Criteria in OMB Circular No. A-11 shall be used in preparing these tabulations.
(5) All items covered by section 6e(4) above shall also be accompanied by estimates of work-years of employment and of personnel required to carry out the proposal in the budget year and four succeeding fiscal years.
- Relationship to advice. Submission of a legislative program to OMB does not constitute a request for advice on individual legislative proposals. Such requests should be made in the manner prescribed in section 7 of this Circular.
- Submission to OMB. Before an agency transmits proposed
legislation or a report (including testimony) outside
the Executive branch, it shall submit the proposed
legislation or report or testimony to OMB for coordination
- Agency scheduling of submissions. Agencies should not
commit themselves to testify on pending bills or to
submit reports or proposed legislation to Congress
on a time schedule that does not allow orderly coordination
and clearance. To facilitate congressional action on
Administration proposals and to forestall hasty, last-minute
clearance requests, agencies should plan their submissions
to OMB on a time schedule that will permit orderly
coordination and clearance. Particular care should
be given to ensuring that draft legislation to carry
out Presidential legislative recommendations is submitted
promptly to OMB to allow sufficient time for analysis
- Timing of agency submissions.
(1) Agencies should submit proposed legislation, reports, and testimony to OMB well in advance of the desired date of transmittal to Congress.
(2) Agencies should include in their submissions to OMB of proposed reports and testimony a copy of any committee request for such reports and testimony, if the request calls for special information or includes specific questions to be covered in the reports or testimony.
(3) Depending on the complexity and significance of the subject matter, the policy issues involved, and the number of agencies affected, an adequate period for clearance by OMB may range from several days to a number of months. Agencies shall consult with OMB staff as to necessary periods for clearance, particularly in cases of major or complex legislation.
(4) On occasion, very short periods for clearances may be unavoidable because of congressional time schedules or other factors. Nevertheless, agencies should make every effort to give OMB a minimum of five full working days for clearance of proposed reports or testimony.
(5) Agencies shall state in their transmittal letters to OMB any information on congressional schedules or other special circumstances that may require expedited clearance.
- Number of copies. Agencies should furnish to OMB 10
copies of proposed legislation and supporting materials
and six copies of draft reports or testimony. If wide
circulation or expedited action is required, the originating
agency shall consult informally in advance with OMB
staff on the number of copies to be supplied. Similarly,
agencies should furnish to OMB six copies of their
views letters on other agencies' proposed legislation,
reports, or testimony.
- Submission of legislation authorizing the enactment of new budget authority.
Section 607 of P.L. 93-344, the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, requires year-ahead requests for authorizing the enactment of new budget authority, as follows:
"Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any request for the enactment of legislation authorizing the enactment of new budget authority to continue a program or activity for a fiscal year (beginning with the fiscal year commencing October 1, 1976) shall be submitted to the Congress not later than May 15 of the year preceding the year in which such fiscal year begins. In the case of a request for the enactment of legislation authorizing the enactment of new budget authority for a new program or activity which is to continue for more than one fiscal year, such request shall be submitted for at least the first 2 fiscal years."
Attachment B sets forth instructions, necessitated by section 607 of P.L. 93-344, for the preparation and submission to Congress of legislative proposals authorizing additional appropriations or providing new budget authority outside of appropriation acts.
- Items to be included in agency submissions.
(1) Agencies should identify proposed legislation submitted to OMB by using the number assigned to the proposal in the agency's legislative program submission; e.g., Agriculture, 96-12 (see Attachment A). Each legislative proposal shall include a draft transmittal letter to the Speaker of the House and the President of the Senate as well as background information and justification, including where applicable:
(a) a section-by-section analysis of the provisions of the proposed legislation;
(b) comparison with existing law presented in "Ramseyer" or "Cordon" rule form by underscoring proposed additions to existing law and bracketing the text of proposed deletions (This need be done only when it would facilitate understanding of the proposed legislation.);
(c) budgetary and personnel impacts as described in sections 6e(4) and (5), including a statement of the relationship of these estimates to those previously incorporated in the President's budgetary program. (Public Law 89-554, 5 U.S.C. 2953, requires in certain cases that agencies, in proposing legislation and in submitting reports favoring legislation, provide estimates of expenditures and personnel that would be needed. Public Law 91-510, sections 252(a) (2U.S.C. 190j) and 252(b) imposes similar requirements on congressional committees.);
(d) comparison with previous agency proposals or related bills introduced in the Congress;
(e) an identification of other agencies that have an interest in the proposal;
(f) an indication of any consultation with other agencies in the development of the proposal; and
(g) information required by statute or by Administration policies, as, for example, that noted in section 7h below.
(2) Similarly, in their letters to OMB requesting advice on reports or testimony, agencies should identify related bills and set forth any relevant comments not included in the report or testimony itself. As indicated in section 7f(1)(c), certain reports or testimony favoring legislation are required by law to include budget and personnel estimates. Where such estimates are not included in other reports or in testimony favoring or opposing legislation, agencies should provide in their letters to OMB a statement of budgetary and personnel impacts as described in sections 6e(4) and (5), including a statement of the relationship of these estimates to those previously incorporated in the President's budgetary program.
(3) In cases where legislation carries out a Presidential recommendation, agencies should include in the proposed report or the letter transmitting proposed legislation a statement identifying the recommendation and indicating the degree to which the legislation concerned will carry it out.
Views letters. In views letters to OMB, an agency should
indicate whether it supports, opposes, or has no objection
to all or part of a pending bill or of another agency's
proposed legislation, report, or testimony and should
state the reasons for its position. If an agency proposes
changes to a pending bill or to another agency's submission,
its views letter should recommend, insofar as practicable,
specific substitute language.
- Certain statutory and other requirements and Administration
policies. Agencies shall carefully consider and take
into account certain requirements of existing statutes
and Executive orders and Administration policies and
directives that are of general applicability. Agency
reports and proposed legislation shall, to the maximum
extent possible, contain or be accompanied by appropriate
recommendations, statements, or provisions to give
effect to such requirements, including but not limited
(1) Civil rights
(2) Environmental impact
(3) Economic impact
(4) Federal budgetary impact and personnel requirements
(5) Federal and non-federal paperwork requirements
(6) State and local government impact
(7) Urban and community impact
- Drafting service. Agencies need not submit for clearance
bills that they prepare as a drafting service for a
congressional committee or a Member of Congress, provided
that they state in their transmittal letters that the
drafting service does not constitute a commitment with
respect to the position of the Administration or the
agency. Agencies shall advise OMB of these drafting
service requests while the requests are being complied
with, and supply a copy of the request, if in writing.
A copy of each such draft bill and the accompanying
letter should be furnished to OMB at the time of transmittal,
together with an explanatory statement of what the
bill would accomplish if that is not contained in the
- Use of "no comment" reports. Agencies should submit no comment reports only when they have no interest in the pending legislation or nothing to contribute by way of informed comment. Agencies should submit such reports for clearance, unless a different procedure is informally arranged with OMB. In either event, they should furnish OMB with one copy of each such report at the time it is transmitted to Congress.
- OMB action on agency submissions.
(1) OMB will undertake the necessary coordination with other interested agencies of an agency's proposed legislation or report. If congressional committees have not requested reports from all of the interested agencies, OMB will request other agency views within specified time limits. OMB will consult with the President, when appropriate, and undertake such staff work for him as may be necessary in cooperation with other Presidential staff. OMB may request the originating agency to provide additional information or may call interagency meetings to exchange views, resolve differences of opinion, or clarify the facts.
(2) When coordination is completed, OMB will transmit advice to the appropriate agencies, either in writing or by telephone. In transmitting advice, OMB may indicate considerations that agencies should or may wish to take into account before submitting proposed legislation or reports to Congress.
- Forms of OMB advice. The exact forms of OMB advice
will vary to suit the particular case. The basic forms
of advice that are commonly used are set forth and
explained in Attachment C.
- Agency action on receipt of advice from OMB.
(1) Agencies shall incorporate the advice received from OMB in their reports and in their letters transmitting proposed legislation to Congress. Advice on testimony is usually not included in the testimony as delivered unless it would be likely to have a significant effect on a committee's consideration of particular legislation or would not otherwise be available to a committee through a written report.
(2) In the case of reports, receipt of advice contrary to views expressed does not require an agency to change its views. In such cases, however, the agency will review its position. If it decides to modify its views, the agency shall consult with OMB to determine what change, if any, in advice previously received is appropriate. If, after the review, the views of the agency are not modified, it shall incorporate in its report the full advice it received.
(3) In the case of proposed legislation, the originating agency shall not submit to Congress any proposal that OMB has advised is in conflict with the program of the President or has asked the agency to reconsider as a result of the coordination process. In such cases, OMB will inform the agency of the reasons for its action.
(4) Agencies are expected to transmit reports and proposed legislation to Congress promptly after receiving OMB clearance. Should circumstances arise that make prompt transmittal inadvisable, the agency shall immediately notify OMB. Similarly, in the case of cleared testimony, the agency shall immediately notify OMB if its testimony has been cancelled or rescheduled.
(5) Agencies should observe the instructions in House and Senate rules to forward proposed legislation or various reports required by law to the Speaker of the House and the President of the Senate. Reports that have been requested by committee chairmen on bills and resolutions pending before their committees should be transmitted directly to the requesting committees.
(6) Agencies shall furnish to OMB two copies of all proposed legislation, transmittal letters and accompanying materials, and reports (including testimony) in the form actually transmitted to the Congress. If reports or testimony cover more than one bill, agencies shall furnish two copies for each bill.
- Agency action where prior clearance has not been effected.
(1) Agencies shall not submit to Congress proposed legislation that has not been coordinated and cleared within the Executive branch in accordance with this Circular.
(2) If congressional time schedules do not allow an agency to send its proposed report to OMB in time for the normal clearance and advice, the agency shall consult informally with OMB as to the advice to be included in the proposed report. OMB may advise the agency to state in its report that time has not permitted securing advice from OMB as to the relationship of the proposed legislation to the program of the President. Agencies shall send to OMB six copies of such reports at the same time that they are transmitted to Congress. Where appropriate, OMB will subsequently furnish advice on the report, which the agency shall transmit promptly to Congress.
(3) In cases where an agency has not submitted a report for clearance and its views on pending legislation are to be expressed in the form of oral, unwritten testimony, OMB will undertake such coordination and give such advice as the circumstances permit. In presenting oral testimony, the agency should indicate what advice, if any, has been received from OMB. If no advice has been obtained, the agency should so indicate.
- Reclearance requirements. The advice received from OMB generally applies to all sessions of each Congress, but it does not carry over from one Congress to the next. Generally, agencies do not need to seek reclearance of reports on which they have already received advice before making the same reports on identical bills introduced in the same Congress, unless considerable time has elapsed or changed conditions indicate that the need for reclearance is appropriate or should be rechecked. Prior to transmitting such reports, however, agencies shall consult informally with appropriate OMB staff to determine whether reclearance is necessary. In cases where reclearance does not take place, agencies shall include in the subsequent report appropriate reference to the advice received on the original report. They shall also send one copy of any subsequent report to OMB at the same time that it is transmitted to Congress. The transmittal letter to OMB should identify the related report that was previously cleared.
9. Interagency Consultation. In carrying out their legislative functions, agencies are encouraged to consult with each other in order that all relevant interests and points of view may be considered and accommodated, where appropriate, in the formulation of their positions. Such consultation is particularly important in cases of overlapping interest, and intensive efforts should be made to reach interagency agreement before proposed legislation or reports are sent to OMB. In order that the President may have the individual views of the responsible heads of the agencies, however, proposed legislation or reports so coordinated shall be sent to OMB by the individual agencies involved, with appropriate reference to the interagency consultation that has taken place.
10. Enrolled Bills. Under the Constitution, the President has 10 days (including holidays but excluding Sundays) to act on enrolled bills after they are presented to him. To assure that the President has the maximum possible time for consideration of enrolled bills, agencies shall give them top priority.
- Initial OMB action. OMB will obtain facsimiles of
enrolled bills from the Government Printing Office
and immediately forward one facsimile to each interested
agency, requesting the agency's views and its recommendation
for Presidential action.
- Agency action. Each agency receiving such a request
shall immediately prepare a letter presenting its views
and deliver it in duplicate to OMB not later than two
days (including holidays but excluding Sundays) after
receipt of the facsimile. OMB may set different deadlines
as dictated by circumstances. Agencies shall deliver
these letters by special messenger to OMB.
- Preparation of enrolled bill letters.
(1) Agencies' letters on enrolled bills are transmitted to the President and should be written so as to assist the President in reaching a decision. Each letter should, therefore, be complete in itself and should not, as a general rule, incorporate earlier reports by reference.
(2) Agencies' letters on enrolled bills are privileged communications, and agencies shall be guided accordingly in determining their content.
(3) Because of the definitive nature of Presidential action on enrolled bills, agency letters shall be signed by a Presidential appointee.
(4) Agencies' letters shall contain:
(a) an analysis of the significant features of the bill including changes from existing law. OMB staff will advise the agencies on which one should write the detailed analysis of the bill where more than one agency is substantially affected;
(b) a comparison of the bill with the Administration proposals, if any, on the same subject;
(c) comments, criticisms, analyses of benefits and shortcomings, or special considerations that will assist the President in reaching a decision;
(d) identification of any factors that make it necessary or desirable for the President to act by a particular date;
(e) an estimate of the first-year and recurring costs or savings and the relationship of the estimates to those previously incorporated in the President's budgetary program;
(f) an estimate of the additional number of personnel required to implement the bill; and
(g) a specific recommendation for approval or disapproval by the President.
(5) Agencies recommending disapproval shall submit with their letters a proposed veto message or memorandum of disapproval, in quadruplicate, prepared on legal-size paper and double-spaced. Such messages or memoranda should be finished products in form and substance that can be used by the President without further revision.
(6) Agencies may wish to recommend issuance of a signing statement by the President. Agencies so recommending shall submit with their letters a draft of such statement, in the same form and quantity as required for a proposed veto message. In some cases, OMB may request an agency to prepare a draft signing statement.
(7) Agencies' letters on private bills shall cite, where appropriate, precedents that support the action they recommend or that need to be distinguished from the action recommended.
- Subsequent OMB action. OMB will transmit agencies' letters to the President, together with a covering memorandum, not later than the fifth day following receipt of the enrolled bill at the White House.
11. Agency legislative liaison officers. To assist in effecting interagency coordination, each agency shall furnish OMB with the name of a liaison officer who has been designated by the agency to handle the coordination of legislative matters under this Circular. From time to time, OMB will send agencies lists of the liaison officers so designated. Agencies should promptly notify OMB of any change in their liaison officers.
- Written agency communications to OMB transmitting proposed legislation, proposed reports, views letters on other agencies' proposed legislation or reports, and letters on enrolled bills should be addressed to:
Director, Office of Management and Budget
Attention: Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
The envelope containing such communications should be addressed:
Legislative Reference Division
Office of Management and Budget
Room 7203, New Executive Office Building
unless a different arrangement is made with an appropriate OMB staff member.
- Questions on status of proposed legislation, reports, testimony, or enrolled bills should be directed to appropriate OMB staff or to the Legislative Information Center (telephone 395-3230).
RELATING TO THE PREPARATION OF
AGENCY LEGISLATIVE PROGRAMS
PART I -- PRESIDENT'S PROGRAM PROPOSALS
Those items that the agency believes are of sufficient importance to be included in the President's legislative program and given specific endorsement by him in one of the regular annual messages, such as the budget message, or in a special message.
PART II -- ALL OTHER PROPOSALS
2. Within each Part, agencies should list the items in order of relative priority. Each item of proposed legislation should be given a separate number for purposes of ready identification, using a numbering system which identifies the Congress; e.g., Agriculture, 96-12.
3. With respect to each item, agencies should provide the following information:
A brief description of the proposal, its objectives,
and its relationship to existing programs. Agencies
should include greater detail on the specific provisions
of proposals included in Part I or where the subject
matter of the proposal contains new policies or programs
or raises complex issues;
Pertinent comments as to timing and readiness of draft
Pertinent references to bills and reports concerning
the subject of the proposal in current or recent sessions
- An estimate for each of the first five fiscal years of (1) any budget authority and outlays that would be required, (2) any savings in budget authority and outlays, (3) any changes in budget receipts, and (4) work years of employment and numbers of personnel. These estimates-should be prepared in accordance with the instructions in OMB Circular No. A-11.
4. The lists of (a) legislative proposals still under consideration in an agency and (b) expiring laws (see section 6 of the Circular) should be presented separately from Parts I and II. The following special instructions apply to them:
- Items still under consideration should be listed
in approximate order of priority and each briefly described
in terms of subject matter and status.
- Each expiring law should be described in terms of (1) the subject, (2) the citation, (3) the date of expiration, (4) the agency's views as to whether the law should be extended or permitted to expire, and (5) other pertinent information. If an agency recommends extension, the proposal should also be included in Part I or Part II, as appropriate.
5. The legislative program submission should be prepared on letter-size paper. General conformance to the format of the attached exhibit will greatly facilitate the use of these programs.
EXHIBIT FOR ATTACHMENT A
Circular No. A-l9
PROPOSED LEGISLATIVE PROGRAM FOR THE ______ SESSION
OF THE ______ CONGRESS
(Items in each Part are listed in order of priority)
PART I -- PRESIDENT'S PROGRAM PROPOSALS
96-3 Amend the provisions of the 1902 Reclamation Act regarding acreage limitation, residency, leasing, excess land sales, the use of Class 1 Equivalency, contracts and contracting procedures, and certain administrative procedures. This proposal would modify and update the acreage limitation provisions of Federal Reclamation law to reflect and accommodate modern agricultural practices, but at the same time retain the basic concept of the Reclamation program--providing opportunities for family farms. The Department has recommended that legislation amending the law reflect the following: Eligibility to receive project water would be limited to adults--18 years of age or older; Residency as provided in the Reclamation Act of 1902, and defined as a maximum distance of 50 miles from the land, would be reimposed on both lessors and lessees of project lands, with specific guidelines for phasing in the requirement; the acreage entitlement for which project water would be available would be increased to 320 acres owned per adult individual, with an additional allowance of 160 acres leased, or the entire 480 acres could be leased (family corporations and multiple ownerships could hold up to 960 acres without regard to the number of people in the arrangement); Class 1 equivalency would be authorized for general use for projects with a frost-free growing season of 180-days or less and would be applied on a project-by-project basis; contracts with districts containing provisions for exemption from acreage limitation provisions upon payout of construction charges would be approved; Sale of excess land by the owner to immediate family members, long-time tenants, employees, or adjoining neighbors would be permitted; Charitable and religious organizations holding project lands on January 1, 1978, would be exempt from acreage limitations. Cost: The estimated cost to the government of administering this proposal would be comparable to the estimated cost of implementing the compliance program under regulations which are being promulgated at this time. The estimated cost of the compliance program for the 5-year period after the final rules are published (not including EIS costs prior to the final rules) is: FY 1980 FY 1981 FY 1982 FY 1983 FY 1984 (millions) 2.4 2.4 2.0 2.0 2.0 Personnel requirements: Estimated personnel requirements are: FY 1980 FY 1981 FY 1982 FY 1983 FY 1984 (work-years) 76 76 64 64 64 (personnel) 85 85 70 70 70
PART II -- ALL OTHER PROPOSALS
96-14 Amend Federal Power Commission Act of 1920. This proposal would amend the Federal Power Commission Act of 1920 to provide that a license will be issued only after the Secretary administering affected public lands makes a determination that the license will not interfere or be inconsistent with the purposes for which such lands are reserved. The Federal Power Commission has interpreted Section 4(e) to require only consideration of the affected Secretary's recommendations. The proposal would also amend the act to provide for extinguishment of withdrawals created by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) applications if the FERC has not responded to the applicant within 6 months or as of date of denial or expiration, surrender, revocation, or termination of the license. Most applications do not result in FPC licenses; yet the land is withdrawn. The administrative process of removing the withdrawals is cumbersome and time consuming and constrains the land managing agency from fully managing these lands for their resource values or from using these lands in exchanges. Revocation of the FERC withdrawal within a specified time period would be consistent with the provisions of Title II of the Federal Lands Policy and Management-Act relating to withdrawals. No additional appropriations or outlays would be required.
INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE PREPARATION AND
SUBMISSION TO CONGRESS OF LEGISLATIVE
PROPOSALS AUTHORIZING THE ENACTMENT OF ADDITIONAL
APPROPRIATIONS OR PROVIDING NEW BUDGET
AUTHORITY OUTSIDE OF APPROPRIATION ACTS
Under section 607 of P.L. 93-344, the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, legislative proposals to extend authorizations scheduled to expire at the end of a given fiscal year should be transmitted to Congress by May 15 of the fiscal year preceding that fiscal year. (For example, if an authorization expired on September 30, 1979, draft legislation to extend the authorization should have been transmitted to Congress by May 15, 1978.) If such proposals were not transmitted or were not enacted, new or revised proposals with language covering the budget year (i.e., the upcoming fiscal year) should be included in the same bill as proposals for the budget year plus one and subsequent years.
- Proposals for agencies and programs that are
customarily authorized on an annual basis (e.g.,
NASA, NSF, State, Justice, Peace Corps, military
procurement and construction) should cover, in the
same bill, proposed language for the budget year
plus one and resubmittals or revisions of previously
proposed authorizations for the budget year. Subsequent
years should also be included if agencies deem it
desirable and feasible.
- Other legislative proposals to extend authorizations
for the enactment of new budget authority expiring
at the end of the budget year should cover, in the
same bill, the budget year plus one and such subsequent
years as is customary or deemed desirable for the
particular program or activity involved.
- Any proposals that provide for authorizations for the budget year or the current fiscal year should be submitted to Congress immediately after OMB clearance.
2. Legislative proposals providing authorizations for new programs or activities.
- Proposals authorizing enactment of budget authority
for a new program or activity should include at least
two fiscal years, unless such new program or activity
is proposed to be effective for only one fiscal year
and to terminate at the end of that year.
- Proposals that provide for authorizations to begin in the budget year plus one should, to the extent feasible, be prepared for submission to Congress no later than May 15 of the current fiscal year.
3. General instructions for legislation authorizing the enactment of new budget authority.
- In keeping with the intent of section 401 of P.L.
93-344, proposals including contract authority or
borrowing authority should provide that such authority
is to be effective only to such extent or in such
amounts as are provided in appropriation acts. Backdoor
financing provisions may be proposed only when the
exceptions set forth in section 401(d) of P.L. 93-344
- As a general rule, bills submitted to Congress authorizing new budget authority for the current fiscal year or budget year will contain specific dollar amounts for those years. These amounts should be those approved for the Budget. For subsequent years, the bills should include "such sums as may be necessary" authorizations unless the agency and OMB agree that special circumstances warrant inclusion of specific amounts.
(1) Where specific amounts are included for years beyond the budget year, those amounts should be consistent with the five-year projections of budget authority printed in the Budget pursuant to P.L. 93-344. Such amounts will be based on the criteria provided for long-range projections in OMB Circular No. A-11.
(2) Authorizing legislation covering principally salaries and administrative expenses which heretofore has been enacted without specific dollar amounts may continue to be proposed for "such sums as may be necessary" for all fiscal years, including the current and budget fiscal years.
- Agencies should draft their authorizing bills to incorporate the highest feasible level of aggregation for new budget authority.
4. Required materials.
Budget year authorization extensions. Proposed
legislation authorizing the continuation of existing
programs in the budget year should have been submitted
to Congress not later than May 15 of the fiscal year
preceding the current fiscal year. In cases where
Congress did not enact budget year authorizations,
new or revised authorizations should be submitted
to Congress at the earliest possible date after the
budget is published.
Accordingly, each agency will submit to OMB no later than December 15 of each year 10 copies of drafts of proposed authorizing legislation to extend programs and activities that are authorized through the current fiscal year, but for which it will be necessary to propose new or revised authorizations for the budget year and subsequent years.
Since the specific amounts of the authorizations to be included cannot be determined until after decisions are made in connection with the budget, the draft bills are submitted to OMB should contain blank spaces for these amounts. When the budget decisions are final, OMB and the agencies will agree on the figures to be inserted.
- Authorization extensions for the budget year plus
one. Proposed legislation authorizing the continuation
of existing programs in the budget year plus one
must be submitted to Congress not later than May
15 of the current fiscal year. To meet this deadline,
sufficient time must be provided for the legislative
coordination and clearance process.
Accordingly, each agency will submit to OMB as early as possible but no later than February 28 of each year 10 copies of legislative proposals for programs and activities that are authorized through the budget year, but for which an authorization request is necessary for the budget year plus one and subsequent years.
These draft legislative proposals should include "such sums as may be necessary" authorizations, unless the agency and OMB agree that special circumstances warrant inclusion of specific amounts. These figures should be the amounts agreed on as a result of the budget review and should be consistent with the five-year projections included in the Budget.
- Authorizations of new programs or activities. In cases where decisions have been made during the budget review calling for authorizing legislation for new programs or activities proposed to begin in the budget year plus one, draft bills reflecting those decisions should be submitted to OMB no later than February 28 of each year, as in paragraph 4b of this Attachment.
BASIC FORMS OF OMB ADVICE
1. "In accord (not in accord) with the program of the President." When an agency or a committee of Congress is advised that enactment of a bill would be in accord with the program of the President, the advice means that the bill is of sufficient importance for the President to give it his personal and public support. That identification of the legislative proposal with the President is made in a variety of ways; e.g., by inclusion in one of his regular messages (State of the Union, Economic, Budget), a special message, speech, press conference, letter, or leadership meeting.
"Not in accord" advice indicates that a bill is so contrary to the President's legislative proposals or other policies or is otherwise so objectionable that should it be enacted in its current form, a veto would be considered. It is not, however, necessarily a commitment to veto.
2. "Consistent with" advice is used where the relationship of a legislative proposal to the Administration's objectives is direct and the Administration's expressed support is desirable, but the item does not warrant personal identification with, or support by, the President. "Not consistent with" advice signals to Congress that there are major objections to a bill, but does not indicate as clearly as "not in accord" advice that a veto would be considered if it were enacted.
3. "No objection from the standpoint of the Administration's program." Advice that there is no objection to a bill from the standpoint of the Administration's program is given on the large number of agency draft bills that deal with matters primarily of agency concern and do not bear a direct or immediate relationship to the President's program or the Administration's objectives. In effect, such advice indicates to Congress that OMB knows of no reason why the President would not approve the bill if Congress should enact it.
Advice to an agency that there is no objection from the standpoint of the Administration's program to its submission of a report (or testimony) on a bill to a committee of Congress does not indicate any commitment as to ultimate Presidential approval or disapproval of the bill if it is enacted. Nevertheless, such "no objection" clearance does set up certain presumptions. If all agencies' views are favorable, the presumption is that no major objection to the bill is known and that the agencies affected will recommend Presidential approval if it becomes enrolled. If all agencies' views are adverse, the presumption is that the agencies may wish to recommend a veto if the bill becomes enrolled.
Infrequently, "no objection" clearance is given to agency reports expressing divergent views on the same bill. When this is done, it normally means that there is no objection to the bill if Congress acts favorably after considering the adverse views. Occasionally, it means that the Administration's position is being reserved pending resolution of the agencies' differences, and this reservation may be explicitly stated. The interested agencies are advised of each other's differing views in these cases.
4. Qualified advice. In some cases the advice given is qualified. For example, the advice may be that there would be no objection to enactment of the bill from the standpoint of the Administration's program, or that the bill would be consistent with the Administration's objectives, if it were revised in specified respects.